Whodunnit?


© 2015 Hy Conrad

During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content. So, the maid wandered up the grand staircase to check on the sleeping children. As soon as she walked into her employer's bedroom, her eagle eyes saw that someone had been there. Taking a towel from her apron, she eradicated the quarter-size water ring from a mahogany table. "How many times do I have to tell Ms. Davis to use a coaster?" Seconds later, a breeze from an open French window drew her outside. Young Andrew's skateboard was on the balcony, right by the railing edge.

"Someone could trip and fall," Patty said with another disapproving cluck. Instinctively, she peered over the railing and was startled to see her prophecy fulfilled. Her employer, the Broadway star Margaret Davis, lay on the flagstone walk, her neck broken but her cut-crystal water glass still in one piece in her hand.

Mr. Davis, Margaret's husband, refilled his brandy snifter twice before his hand was steady enough to dial up the police. Clark Burton, Margaret's costar, seemed just as inconsolable. All night he'd been drinking shot glasses of whiskey. But the tragic accident sobered him instantly. Margaret's understudy, Elizabeth Harris, had never held much affection for the star, especially since Margaret had never once missed a performance. But now, Elizabeth put down her beer mug and became the picture of solicitude and mourning. "Whatever we do, we mustn't ever let poor Andrew know it was his skateboard that made his mother slip."

"It wasn't the skateboard," Patty muttered darkly. "Ms. Davis was pushed over that railing. And I know who did it."

Okay, Nancy Drews and Sherlock Holmes. Take out your magnifying glasses. I want you to answer my questions:

1. How does Patty know it wasn't an accident?

2. Who's the suspect and why?

 

You need to be a member of MyEnglishClub to add comments!

Join MyEnglishClub

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Well, I send Mr. Conrad an email and the answer is as follows:

    If Margaret had tripped on the skateboard, it would not have wound up right by the railing. It would have been pushed backwards.
    Unfortunately, Patty accidentally destroyed the most telling piece of evidence, the water ring on the table. The offending glass had been the size of a quarter, much too small for a crystal water glass, a brandy snifter, or a beer mug. It's just the right size for a shot glass, however. The killer had to be Clark Burton.

    Congrat, Zahra! You solved the case.

  • ''the conclusion''?

    I dunno. Maybe it's one of those unsolved murder-mystery cases. =/

    Kidding! Imma contact Hy and ask him personally.

    Wish me luck!
    Zahra said:


    Interesting!

    Let's see the conclusion!


    Peppo said:

    Well Ladies,. hope you all care to let me in, lol xD This case is just so interesting and intriguing for me who is not typicaly nancy drew and sherlock holmes, all i have just common sense, heee...

    let's get straight to the point,.

    1. Patty know it wasn't an accident because she realized someone had been there, she thought it was her employer, Margaret Davis, from the quarter-size water ring from a mahogany table she eradicated. Later she knew that Margaret's cut-crystal water glass still in one piece in her hand. it means she was with somebody else who didn't use coaster and left that mark.

    2. The suspect is -in my opinion- her own husband, Mr. Davis. Because the accident took place in their bedroom. so, i guess it was only they who could get in and out as they wish. Another assumtion is coming from the first paragraph, "During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content." indicated that patty had seen all the guests but the owner of the house, Mr and Mrs Davis. 

    That's all from me, wish me right, lol xD 

    Whodunnit?
    © 2015 Hy Conrad During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content. So, the…

  • Interesting!

    Let's see the conclusion!


    Peppo said:

    Well Ladies,. hope you all care to let me in, lol xD This case is just so interesting and intriguing for me who is not typicaly nancy drew and sherlock holmes, all i have just common sense, heee...

    let's get straight to the point,.

    1. Patty know it wasn't an accident because she realized someone had been there, she thought it was her employer, Margaret Davis, from the quarter-size water ring from a mahogany table she eradicated. Later she knew that Margaret's cut-crystal water glass still in one piece in her hand. it means she was with somebody else who didn't use coaster and left that mark.

    2. The suspect is -in my opinion- her own husband, Mr. Davis. Because the accident took place in their bedroom. so, i guess it was only they who could get in and out as they wish. Another assumtion is coming from the first paragraph, "During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content." indicated that patty had seen all the guests but the owner of the house, Mr and Mrs Davis. 

    That's all from me, wish me right, lol xD 

    Whodunnit?
    © 2015 Hy Conrad During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content. So, the…
  • Not them. He looks like one. You don't see that?


    Peppo said:

    did you say about 'turtle'? 2643671243?profile=original

    Whodunnit?
    © 2015 Hy Conrad During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content. So, the…
  • did you say about 'turtle'? 2643671546?profile=original

  • I'm thinkin' of a turtle...

    Is that bad? =p
    Peppo said:

    Alright xD
    2643671303?profile=original



    A738a said:

    'Course! The more the merrier. Welcome aboard!

    The suspect is -in my opinion- her own husband...

    ''A woman has been killed.''

    ''Oh, arrest her husband.''  

    And vice versa.

    Classic.

     


    Peppo said:

    Well Ladies,. hope you all care to let me in, lol xD This case is just so interesting and intriguing for me who is not typicaly nancy drew and sherlock holmes, all i have just common sense, heee...

    let's get straight to the point,.

    1. Patty know it wasn't an accident because she realized someone had been there, she thought it was her employer, Margaret Davis, from the quarter-size water ring from a mahogany table she eradicated. Later she knew that Margaret's cut-crystal water glass still in one piece in her hand. it means she was with somebody else who didn't use coaster and left that mark.

    2. The suspect is -in my opinion- her own husband, Mr. Davis. Because the accident took place in their bedroom. so, i guess it was only they who could get in and out as they wish. Another assumtion is coming from the first paragraph, "During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content." indicated that patty had seen all the guests but the owner of the house, Mr and Mrs Davis. 

    That's all from me, wish me right, lol xD 

    Whodunnit?
    © 2015 Hy Conrad During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content. So, the…
  • Alright xD
    2643671144?profile=original



    A738a said:

    'Course! The more the merrier. Welcome aboard!

    The suspect is -in my opinion- her own husband...

    ''A woman has been killed.''

    ''Oh, arrest her husband.''  

    And vice versa.

    Classic.

     


    Peppo said:

    Well Ladies,. hope you all care to let me in, lol xD This case is just so interesting and intriguing for me who is not typicaly nancy drew and sherlock holmes, all i have just common sense, heee...

    let's get straight to the point,.

    1. Patty know it wasn't an accident because she realized someone had been there, she thought it was her employer, Margaret Davis, from the quarter-size water ring from a mahogany table she eradicated. Later she knew that Margaret's cut-crystal water glass still in one piece in her hand. it means she was with somebody else who didn't use coaster and left that mark.

    2. The suspect is -in my opinion- her own husband, Mr. Davis. Because the accident took place in their bedroom. so, i guess it was only they who could get in and out as they wish. Another assumtion is coming from the first paragraph, "During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content." indicated that patty had seen all the guests but the owner of the house, Mr and Mrs Davis. 

    That's all from me, wish me right, lol xD 

  • 'Course! The more the merrier. Welcome aboard!

    The suspect is -in my opinion- her own husband...

    ''A woman has been killed.''

    ''Oh, arrest her husband.''  

    And vice versa.

    Classic.

     


    Peppo said:

    Well Ladies,. hope you all care to let me in, lol xD This case is just so interesting and intriguing for me who is not typicaly nancy drew and sherlock holmes, all i have just common sense, heee...

    let's get straight to the point,.

    1. Patty know it wasn't an accident because she realized someone had been there, she thought it was her employer, Margaret Davis, from the quarter-size water ring from a mahogany table she eradicated. Later she knew that Margaret's cut-crystal water glass still in one piece in her hand. it means she was with somebody else who didn't use coaster and left that mark.

    2. The suspect is -in my opinion- her own husband, Mr. Davis. Because the accident took place in their bedroom. so, i guess it was only they who could get in and out as they wish. Another assumtion is coming from the first paragraph, "During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content." indicated that patty had seen all the guests but the owner of the house, Mr and Mrs Davis. 

    That's all from me, wish me right, lol xD 

    Whodunnit?
    © 2015 Hy Conrad During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content. So, the…
  • What's wrong with an eyepatch?

    tumblr_m85cu92SX01rw4k4fo1_500.gifI'm totally hearing Berrnard Herrmann's Twisted Nerve right now. How could you not murder some, um, ''something'' to this song?


    MARY said:

    Oh! And if there is someone with an eye patch, I'm suspicious too!

    fry_squinting.gif

    Whodunnit?
    © 2015 Hy Conrad During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content. So, the…
  • Don't you know if it isn't the butler, it's the maid?
    But in this case, I don't think so.
    MARY said:

    hahhaha poor Zahra! XD

    Well, I've always been kind of 'lazy' for this kind of literature, but I'm always suspicious about the maid or butler :P



    Zahra said:

    For the sake of God, someone please solve the puzzle! I am too lazy to make my mind work on it anymore!

    Whodunnit?
    © 2015 Hy Conrad During the big party, Patty got tired of dealing with the guests. They all had drinks in hand and seemed perfectly content. So, the…
This reply was deleted.