ESL Discussion

Does woman deserve to shout??

Posted by Diah on August 27, 2017 in General Discussion

I know that man and woman are created in different soul, body shape, etc. I know that they have different rules in society like "Woman should can cook for the family" or "Man should treat the woman gently".

Then what brings me into the discussion is when my mom said "A woman does not deserve to shout at home, so it can be heard by the neighbors".

Is it true? So woman does not deserve to shout while the man does? Please help me to understand this statement. I can't catch this correctly.  

Views: 18

You need to be a member of MyEnglishClub to add comments!

Join MyEnglishClub

★
★
★
★
★
Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –
Follow

Replies

  • pint September 6, 2017 7:38

    No problem, Diah. Nice topic.
     


    Diah said:

    Hi pint! Yeah i do agree with you. Thank you for your great comment!
    Does woman deserve to shout??
    I know that man and woman are created in different soul, body shape, etc. I know that they have different rules in society like Woman should can coo…
  • Diah September 5, 2017 10:17
    Hi khim! Eventually it depends on the person 's belief itself. Thanks for the nice comment!
  • Diah September 5, 2017 10:15
    Hi pint! Yeah i do agree with you. Thank you for your great comment!
  • Khim September 4, 2017 14:47

    Hi!

    Personally, I believe anyone is entitled to express their opinions, (whether its out of happiness or rage) and yelling/shouting is one of them, sometimes you just have to  given there is a justifiable reason to shout. While in some culture, shouting is frowned upon I still think it depends on the person's belief.

  • pint September 4, 2017 9:09

    I think shouting is something you shouldn't do both men and women, somehow It's very appropriate in some occasions and places like having fun with friends playing games with family.

    Prohibit specifically to women is unfair in my opinion. In someway It make one more gentle and seem to be quite kind.

  • Diah September 4, 2017 0:11

    Obviously, Eman! Thanks for sharing your good opinion here

    Eman said:

    I think nobody desrves to shout apart from gender. All should try to practice talking gently ....
    Does woman deserve to shout??
    I know that man and woman are created in different soul, body shape, etc. I know that they have different rules in society like Woman should can coo…
  • Diah September 2, 2017 7:36

    Hey, Luci! Yes, I agree. However, we need to release our stress of something because if it only be held in ourselves, it can be more harmful once it is release!

    Luci said:

    Hello Diah,
    it is individual I would say and also sth related to your personality...some people can hardly control themself and shouting is totally normal for them :D anyway... I think both genders are equal and can shout as much as they can at each other till they don't hurt or kill themself and I even can assure you that it is healthy to scream out your emotiins instead of supressing your anger and pain inside of you :) to be obedient girl is nice but it might lead you to unbearable depressions - this is my point ;)
    Does woman deserve to shout??
    I know that man and woman are created in different soul, body shape, etc. I know that they have different rules in society like Woman should can coo…
  • Diah September 2, 2017 7:26

    Oh well... i see it now. Thanks for the comment!

    SaLeM said:

     Sometimes badthings happen between husband and his wife so that a husband lose his nerves then begins to shout .

    The job presures , the way people deal with him some diffrent situations...etc so he comes home then just when some bad things happen because of children or even wife so he starts to shout ,that is all

    Does woman deserve to shout??
    I know that man and woman are created in different soul, body shape, etc. I know that they have different rules in society like Woman should can coo…
  • Luci August 31, 2017 7:49
    Hello Diah,
    it is individual I would say and also sth related to your personality...some people can hardly control themself and shouting is totally normal for them :D anyway... I think both genders are equal and can shout as much as they can at each other till they don't hurt or kill themself and I even can assure you that it is healthy to scream out your emotiins instead of supressing your anger and pain inside of you :) to be obedient girl is nice but it might lead you to unbearable depressions - this is my point ;)
  • Roman August 30, 2017 22:57

    Rosemary! I wander how can you always find such great phrases of the famous peole around the world! I like it! I like this phrase very much! Thank you!

    Rosemary said:

          Actually i didn't understand what do mean exactly . However , in Arabic culture a women should not shout in the face of the man or act like him  .This is not acceptable   . In real world  ,  i do shout a lot at my kids . 

       There are many pressures  i must shout sometimes :(  . Some women never shout they are under the tradition control  .Both sides are suffering  , shouting leads to nowhere and keeping ur mouth shut may drives u to a mental illness  . We need to clam down and control our anger and emotions  , because  , bad negative things will exhaust us and prevent us from enjoying our life

                  2643990761?profile=original 

    Does woman deserve to shout??
    I know that man and woman are created in different soul, body shape, etc. I know that they have different rules in society like Woman should can coo…
This reply was deleted.

Report discussion